Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.
Rugby Union

News

Ireland still upset

Ireland still upset

02/07/2012 06:27:10 PM

Ireland's sense of grievance over the manner of Sunday's Six Nations defeat by Wales intensified on Tuesday when Stephen Ferris was cited for his 'tip tackle' on Ian Evans.

Ferris will appear before an independent disciplinary committee in London at lunchtime on Wednesday (UK time) to explain the incident that unfolded in the final minute of a thrilling and controversial afternoon at Lansdowne Road.

The challenge resulted in referee Wayne Barnes issuing a yellow card and penalty, which Leigh Halfpenny landed to snatch victory for Wales.

Many observers felt the tackle, in which Ferris picked up Evans by his right leg and dumped him on his side, warranted a penalty at worst.

Team manager Michael Kearney, who will accompany Ferris to the hearing, is 'hopeful' the 26-year-old Ulster flanker will be cleared.

"Stephen is very disappointed. He's not a player who has been guilty of any form of foul play in his entire career," said Kearney.

"He has played 31 times for Ireland and has never received so much as a yellow card.

"The last yellow card he received was more than two years ago [with Ulster] and he has never once received a yellow card for any form of foul play.

"My view is that it wasn't a foul. I've looked at the footage again.

"Stephen certainly didn't drive the player up and take both feet off the ground.

"The player was never on the horizontal, his left foot remained on the ground for the entire incident.

"We're very disappointed with the card and penalty, but even more disappointed that he's been cited as well.

"He trained this afternoon and he will get on with it. We're hopeful he'll get the right outcome, which is no suspension."

The failure of Barnes to show Wales lock Bradley Davies a straight red card for a far more alarming example of the same offence 15 minutes earlier has only heightened the feeling of injustice.

Inexplicably, touch judge Dave Pearson, who was perfectly sighted, declined to advise Barnes that Davies should be sent off, instead stating the sin-bin was sufficient punishment.

Even Wales coach Warren Gatland accepted Davies should have been dismissed for the challenge on replacement Donnacha Ryan.

Adding a twist to Saturday's crucial showdown with France, which Ireland must win if they are to rescue their Six Nations, is that Pearson will be the referee.

Davies, whose hearing is on Wednesday morning, and Ferris have been cited for the same offence, which is defined under the International Rugby Board's Law 10.4 (j).

It states: "Lifting a player from the ground, and dropping or driving that player into the ground whilst that player's feet are still off the ground such that the player's head and/or upper body come into contact with the ground, is dangerous play."

While the tip tackles were clearly at different ends of the spectrum, Ferris could be suspended as part of the IRB's drive to rid the game of such a dangerous offence.

The low end entry level sanction is three weeks, though this can be reduced on such grounds as contrition or a clean disciplinary record.

Tip or spear tackling was brought into sharp focus during the semi-finals of last year's World Cup when Sam Warburton was shown a red card for upending France winger Vincent Clerc.

Warburton's dismissal initially provoked outrage, but this was later replaced by an acceptance that referee Alain Rolland had made the correct call.

Ireland

 
Photograph Copyright : Getty Images
Page12»

Latest Headlines

McKenzie optimistic against Brumbies
05/25/2012 09:58:37 PM
 
Wade handed England chance
05/25/2012 08:33:24 PM
 
Chiefs counter structured Bulls
05/25/2012 01:35:01 PM
 
Quick throw the game-changer
05/25/2012 01:15:39 PM
 
Chiefs secure thriller in Hamilton
05/25/2012 09:15:47 AM
 
 
 

Your Say

Galleries

Rugby World Cup Finals
25/10/2011 11:22:46 AM
Did you miss the action from the recent finals of the Rugby World Cup? Don’t worry, we will take you back and show you best action from the Quarter Finals through to the Final.
The Weekend Sporting Action
18/10/2011 2:21:08 PM
The sport never slows down around the world. Check out the latest action from the weekend.