Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.

News

 
 
Netball too physical

Netball too physical

06/28/2010 11:52:48 PM

It's official. Netball has become too physical, to the point where coaches are criticising the way the game is being played.

Following the Waikato/Bay of Plenty Magic's 50-42 ANZ Championship minor semi-final victory over the Southern Steel on Monday, 12-year coaching veteran Robyn Broughton and Magic coach Noeline Taurua opened up about their fears for netball.

Their comments are from the same song sheet as those from Silver Ferns goal shoot Irene van Dyk who told Sportal she believed the 'biff' in netball was nullifying skill.

Broughton said players would have to adopt a totally different approach if the style continued.

"All teams have got more physical as the season went on," the Steel coach said.

"You have to be able to throw the ball under physical pressure, and throw it accurately. If that's the way the game's going to go then your whole training needs to start differently and things need to change because it's a lot more confrontational. You saw it yesterday [Sunday] with the Swifts and Thunderbirds."

When asked has it gone too far? Broughton replied: "I think so because you lose some of the skill. Instead of being able to get rid of it all the time, the game is stopped. There's no running, jumping and releasing in the air."

Her views were taken even further from the victorious coach, who said her side had entered its two previous playoff campaigns soft, but it had learnt from its mistakes and would adopt a far more ruthless approach against the Sydney Swifts in the preliminary final in Newcastle on Sunday.

To prepared for that match, the No.1 New Zealand side would use hit shield and have bags shoved in their faces at training to harden up, Taurua said.

"The game's definitely changing a huge amount. It's very competitive. We've spoken to the umpires about what's competing on the ball - and what's just downright dirty," she said.

"What's netball about? In Australia, it's dog eat dog. It's a totally different look. When New Zealand teams go over there we suffer because we play a different game."

In 60 minutes at Vector Arena, the Magic were hit with 58 contacts and the Steel 45 (103 total) - almost two per-minute.

Visiting captain and goal attack Megan Dehn, who was outstanding with 24/25 shooting attempts, highlighted what was disappearing from the game.

"You play to what the umpires let you get away with. It's definitely very physical. It makes the game very stop start and you don't get too many nice passages of play," she said.

Their views are clear - something has to change, or get used to physical confrontation in netball.

 
Photograph Copyright : Getty Images

Latest Headlines

 
 
Preview: Australia v New Zealand
Preview: Australia v New Zealand
Netball
Wednesday 18th July at 7.30pm NZT
 
 
 
 

Your Say

 
 

Galleries

 
 
Super Bowl XLVI
6/02/2012 7:21:01 PM
The New York Giants are the world champions for the second time in four years after a dramatic Super Bowl victory over the New England Patriots in Indianapolis.
2012 Australian Open: Final
30/01/2012 1:05:03 PM
Victoria Azarenka claimed her first ever Grand Slam title while Novak Djokovic and Rafael Nadal produced one of the most remarkable tennis matches of all time.
 
2012 Australian Open: Semi Finals
28/01/2012 1:37:46 AM
Nadal and Djokovic will meet each-other in the Australian Open Men's Final and Azarenka will battle Sharapova in the Women's Final. Here's all the semi-final action.
 
Photos of the Week
28/11/2011 3:33:38 PM
The golf season is getting into full swing; A League is continuing plus heaps more. So take a break from work and look thought the photo gallery of the week’s best sporting action.
Australia Day at the Masters
15/04/2011 1:02:25 PM
We take a look at Australians Jason Day, Adam Scott and Geoff Ogilvy's performance in the US Masters.